Source: Shanghai Elevator Technology Training Center
As China’s urban development accelerates, high-rise construction expands, energy-efficient elevators become more widespread, and the World Expo draws near, the global elevator industry has experienced substantial growth, driven by the country’s robust economic development. China’s elevator production has continuously reached new highs: approximately 110,000 units in 2004 and 170,000 units in 2007. Today, China has become both the world’s largest elevator market and its largest producer. Shanghai alone boasts over 100,000 elevators, more than 120 elevator manufacturers, and 240 maintenance firms, with 38,000 professionals employed in installation and repair—yet highly skilled personnel (technicians and senior technicians) account for only 1.3% of this workforce. Shanghai aims to increase the share of highly skilled workers to over 25% of all skilled laborers by the end of the Eleventh Five-Year Plan period, with young and mid-career high-tech talent under 45 comprising roughly 80% of that group. However, the proportion of highly skilled personnel in the elevator sector remains far below Shanghai’s target.
I. Current Shortage of Highly Skilled Personnel in Shanghai’s Elevator Industry
In recent years, as employment pressure on university graduates has increased significantly, another social issue has emerged: a severe shortage of skilled technical personnel in enterprises, particularly highly skilled workers. According to our statistics, Shanghai’s elevator manufacturing, installation, and maintenance sectors face a shortfall of 20,000 senior technicians. Currently, the city’s elevator industry experiences supply falling short of demand across all levels, from senior technicians to master craftsmen and senior master craftsmen. This shortage of highly skilled talent has become a bottleneck to the development of elevator companies. If this situation is not promptly addressed, it could undermine the technological advancement and growth potential of the elevator industry throughout Shanghai and even nationwide.
II. Shortage of Highly Skilled Personnel in Shanghai’s Elevator Industry
(1) The mistaken notion that “academic education is valued more than vocational education, and academic credentials are prioritized over vocational skills” is the primary ideological root of the shortage of highly skilled personnel.
For a long time, many of our enterprises have suffered from a distribution mechanism in which, no matter how well skilled workers perform, their status and income still lag behind those of highly educated technical personnel. This has fostered a societal perception that one should avoid becoming a worker at all costs. Many parents discourage, or even actively oppose, their children attending vocational schools. Some skills‑training institutions have been forced to close due to insufficient enrollment. According to our surveys, in Shanghai’s suburban districts, 80% of parents hope their children will attain at least an associate degree; in the urban areas, over 90% aspire to a bachelor’s degree or higher. Moreover, more than 90% of parents are reluctant to let their children learn a trade and become workers. Our educational philosophy continues to prioritize academic degrees while neglecting vocational education and the cultivation of skilled professionals, leading to situations where technical schools are compelled to shut down for lack of students.
(2) The current education system and the mechanisms for cultivating highly skilled personnel have significant shortcomings.
The design of majors and curricula in higher vocational and technical education has not been oriented toward market demand, resulting in considerable arbitrariness. Major offerings and instructional content are severely disconnected from reality and fail to keep pace with the rapid development of manufacturing and the apparel industry. Insufficient information exchange and loose collaboration between schools and enterprises make it difficult for graduates to meet industry needs. Meanwhile, a lack of funding and equipment limits the training capacity and level of vocational and technical institutions, leaving them unable to satisfy the demands of new occupations, technologies, and processes. Furthermore, the faculty at these institutions cannot adequately address current technical and skill requirements, so much so that college graduates find themselves ill-equipped to undertake modern elevator machinery installation and maintenance work.
(3) The extent to which enterprises prioritize vocational training and the awareness of the employees themselves
State-owned and private enterprises exhibit two distinct approaches to cultivating highly skilled personnel. First, leaders in large and medium-sized enterprises demonstrate a certain degree of enthusiasm and guidance in training and upskilling their employees, with wages and benefits tied to skill levels. Second, some enterprise leaders fail to take a leading role in enhancing employee skills, resulting in severely inadequate investment in skills training. Profitable firms are reluctant to invest, while less profitable ones lack the financial capacity to do so. Following changes in operating mechanisms, some enterprises adopt short-term, profit‑driven strategies, prioritizing immediate utilization over training—sometimes even employing workers without providing any training at all.
Currently, within the elevator industry, there are three distinct groups among the workforce: First, employees—both Shanghai residents and non‑Shanghai residents—in state‑owned and private enterprises who hold certain positions or rights within their organizations. This group possesses an intrinsic motivation to acquire skills, viewing professional certification as a source of pride and social distinction. Second, primarily laid‑off or unemployed workers; some demonstrate a proactive attitude toward skill acquisition, driven by the need to secure basic livelihoods. However, they generally have lower educational attainment, are older, require longer training periods, and exhibit slower learning curves. Third, mainly migrant laborers; a subset has been engaged in relatively stable employment for extended periods and is motivated to learn new skills to improve their circumstances. These individuals tend to be better educated, resilient, diligent, and eager to learn. Another segment is driven solely by survival needs, has lower educational levels, approaches training perfunctorily, and lacks the fundamental aptitude required to master advanced skills.
(4) No mechanisms have been established for the evaluation, motivation, and mobility of highly skilled personnel.
Regarding the evaluation of technical personnel, barriers based on quotas, age, seniority, and status persist, and a new assessment system has yet to be established—one that is competency‑driven, emphasizes job performance, and places due weight on professional ethics and knowledge. As for motivating skilled workers, enterprises—particularly state‑owned firms that employ a relatively large number of highly skilled employees—have failed to implement income‑distribution mechanisms that encourage frontline production and operations staff to deepen their technical expertise and enhance their overall capabilities. Outside the enterprise, the lack of a flexible mobility framework for skilled professionals prevents them from realizing their full value through career transitions, thereby hindering the gradual improvement of the human capital return on investment and the goal of incentivizing such talent to invest in their own development.
III. Addressing the Shortage of Highly Skilled Talent
(1) Reassess the value and status of skilled professionals, and foster a positive environment that respects and cherishes technical talent.
Enhance the professional sense of honor, pride, and responsibility among highly skilled personnel. The government should provide more proactive policy guidance and offer appropriate benefits to these individuals. Advanced technical schools can evolve into high‑level vocational institutions through mergers or restructuring, enabling skilled workers to acquire theoretical knowledge and earn associate’s, bachelor’s, or even higher degrees. The experiences of developed countries in viewing vocational and academic education are worth emulating. For example, the United Kingdom’s National Vocational Qualifications system fully equates the ranks of skilled workers with those of academically trained professionals. The social status and income of senior skilled workers are in no way inferior to those of PhDs or master’s degree holders. The government should encourage and support societal organizations and industry enterprises in launching initiatives that highlight exemplary highly skilled individuals—such as organizing skill competitions and exchanges at various levels—to motivate skilled workers to study scientific and technological knowledge, improve their abilities, and cultivate a positive public image.
(II) Improving the Mechanism for Cultivating Highly Skilled Personnel
Vocational training schools across all disciplines should align their educational philosophies, program development, management models, and institutional frameworks with market dynamics and employment outcomes. They should accelerate reforms in teaching methodologies and administrative systems, adopt flexible academic regulations, strengthen school–enterprise partnerships, vigorously promote “menu‑style” training programs, enhance vocational skills training, implement a dual‑certification system combining academic degrees and professional qualifications, and expedite the rejuvenation and rapid growth of the highly skilled workforce.
(3) Improve the training mechanism for highly skilled personnel in enterprises
First, a system of regular professional development and training for highly skilled personnel should be established to ensure that training is standardized and institutionalized, keeping technical expertise in step with enterprise development. Second, multidisciplinary talent training should be conducted to increase the proportion of “specialized yet versatile” highly skilled workers within the enterprise workforce. Third, skills training should be integrated with theoretical education and linked to projects such as technological upgrading and technology acquisition. Fourth, investment in training must be increased, and employees should be encouraged to take pride in learning and improving their skills. Fifth, government support for training should be strengthened, with policy incentives offered to institutions capable of cultivating highly skilled personnel. Sixth, the master-apprentice mentoring system should be improved to enable more young skilled workers to develop into highly skilled professionals more rapidly. The government should guide and oversee the implementation of corporate employee training budgets, ensuring effective monitoring and enforcing appropriate rewards and penalties.
(4) Establish and improve mechanisms for the evaluation, incentive, and mobility of highly skilled personnel in enterprises.
Enterprises should first create more opportunities for highly skilled personnel to learn and advance, enabling them to continuously realize their self-worth by offering greater prospects for growth. Second, they should accelerate the establishment of a new evaluation system for skilled talent that is oriented toward professional competence, emphasizes job performance, and places importance on professional ethics and knowledge levels. Barriers related to quotas, age, qualifications, and employment status must be broken down to foster faster and better development of highly skilled personnel. A personnel management mechanism should be gradually put in place whereby employees are employed and promoted based on their skills and professional qualifications, and income distribution is determined by performance contributions. The wages, benefits, and overall compensation packages for highly skilled personnel must be continuously improved, with senior skilled workers, technicians, and senior technicians eventually enjoying equal treatment—regarding professional titles and remuneration—as their corresponding professional and technical counterparts.